2). I’ve
added Australian
tanker’s criticism of the T-34 tank and Combat
report of Soviet 10th Tank division - August 1941 in the Index.
3). I’ve
added information in WWII
Myths - T-34 Best Tank of the war. Specifically:
In paragraph Problematic gearbox: ‘However it seems
that even vehicles built late in the war were not guaranteed to have the new
5-speed gearbox. The tanks given to the Polish People's Army in late 1944/early
1945 and those used by the North Korean Army in 1950 had the old 4-speed setup
(6).’
In paragraph Reliability problems: ‘Soviet tests on
newly built T-34’s (14) showed that
in April 1943 only 10.1% could complete a 330km trial and in June ’43 this went
down to 7.7%. The percentage stayed below 50% till October 1943 when it rose to
78%, in the next month it dropped to 57% and in the period December ’43 -
February ’44 the average was 82%.’
In paragraph T-34 vs M4 Sherman: ‘The Sherman proved
its superiority in the Korean war, when US M4 tanks demolished the North Korean
armored units equipped with the T-34/85.’
In paragraph Conclusion: ‘In the Korean conflict of
1950-53 the T-34/85 again suffered disproportionate losses against Allied
vehicles with comparable capabilities. The opinion of a Royal New Zealand
Armoured Corps tanker is worth reading (28):
‘And now, Sir, a few words for your private
ear on the T 34. I assume that the tks given by Joe to Mr. Wu are old models.
Even so they were grossly overrated in press reports in the early days of the
KOREAN Camaign. (A well placed HE shell from a 20 pr will lift the turret off).
Only about 4 per Sqn have wrls and their armour is of poor quality. The whole
tk is of the crudest workmanship, and breaks down with the greatest ease. (In
fairness I must add that this may be due to inexperienced CHINESE crew). They
would have to be used in mass, RUSSIAN fashion, to be any treat to a well
trained, well equipped Army, as they have been proved somewhat inferior to the
SHERMAN. A CENTURION will do to them what a TIGER did to the SHERMAN. They got
their initial build up as a scapegoat to cover the natural and understandable,
fact that the first American tps over here were raw, frightened boys who were
also soft from occupational duties in JAPAN. The T 34, I am convinced, should
be de-bunked. It is a workable tk, but NOT a wonder tk’.
Very fascinating read indeed on Suvorov. I really do hope that we will get a good book that brings all of this together because we really don't seem to have the whole story on the eastern front or indeed the whole war .
ReplyDeleteI’m not optimistic.
Delete